Letters to the Editor

By Readers

Ethical business

The winter edition has a five-page article (“Take Your Conscience to Work”) discussing business ethics and how well Notre Dame has addressed ethics in business. On the very next page there is an article questioning whether Notre Dame has too many business majors. Given the ethical condition of corporate America, shouldn’t the question be whether Notre Dame has enough

Read More

Letters to the editor: Web extra

By Readers

Harsh statement
Surviving in Manhattan makes some people overly defensive and brash, as Christina Conklin describes in her fine article, “Would it kill you to be nice?” If only that struggle were unique to New York. A letter to the editor in the winter issue complains about how “evil” a Notre Dame professor is and that he “should burn in hell for eternity.” I would appreciate never reading such a letter again in this magazine. Even our hardened Manhattan alumni know we are leaven in the modern world, not judges of damnation in the next!…

Read More

React Online: The Soul of a University

By Readers

Editor’s note: The following letters were received through the magazine’s React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine.

Reading Mr. Anthony DePalma’s article on the “Soul of a University” was both moving and enlightening. As the parent of an only child, who is currently a senior in high school, I am fraught with anxiety about letting go while being concerned whether my child will be well taken care off at the college she selects to attend and still get an excellent education that will help her prepare well for a productive future.…

Read More

Letters to the editor — web extra

By Readers

*Oh, Those Indulgences*

I just read "Escape From Purgatory" by John M. Nichols in your Spring 2004 issue. Not only was there much truth in the article, but it was also written in such a comical way it was a joy to read. I think you should have Mr. Nichols submit an article for each issue. Rest assured your readers would turn to his writing before reading anything else in each issue.…

Read More

React Online: The Soul of a University

By Readers

_Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine._ Reading Mr. Anthony DePalma's article on the "Soul of a University" was both moving and enlightening. As the parent of an only child, who is currently a senior in high school, I am fraught with anxiety about letting go while being concerned whether my child will be well taken care off at the college she selects to attend and still get an excellent education that will help her prepare well for a productive future.

The article was very enlightening for Mr. DePalma's insights both as a parent and as a student as well as one who has had a rich and varied perspective of college life and quality here in America.…

Read More

Letters to the Editor

By Readers

Notre Dame

I took the old collegiate seminar ("A Death in the Curriculum") under an infuriating fellow named Daniel Koob, even complained to a dean about the demands and hated the required aggravations . . . until about midyear, when I discovered I was breathing outside the womb—and wanted to be there! Basically, I had learned to read—not just the text at hand, but _all_ texts, incorporating both intellect and value base.…

Read More

The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name, p. 2

By Readers

_Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine._ "Page 1":/news/10626, "Page 3":/news/10628, "Page 4":/news/10629, "Page 5":/news/10630 It is with regret that I hereby request that you remove my name from your list of subscribers. I have for many years enjoyed keeping up with goings on at Notre Dame through the magazine. Your current issue, however, sadly demonstrates an editorial philosophy that I cannot find edifying and must protest against.

I am greatly disturbed by Mr. Temple's statement in his editor's note that: "Homosexuality is . . . a fascinatingly rich subject that gets into human nature, love and sexual attraction; brings together science, psychology, sociology and religion; that involves family, morality and cultural mores; that raises questions of Catholic doctrine and the individual's conscience."…

Read More

The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name, p. 3

By Readers

_Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine_ "Page 1":/news/10626, "Page 2":/news/10627, "Page 4":/news/10629, "Page 5":/news/10630 Finally, some diversity in an otherwise secular, mundane and pandering magazine. This is the first issue I actually read cover to cover. Some of the other online comments prove that the hate, prejudice and disdain that gay people face every day is real. I find it unfortunate that these comments come from supposedly well-educated Christian alum. Gay students have always been and always will be a part of the ND community. Not acknowledging them will not make them go away. This issue should have been published 20 years ago.

Mark Bomber '86
Denver, Colorado…

Read More

The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name, p. 4

By Readers

_Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine_ "Page 1":/news/10626, "Page 2":/news/10627, "Page 3":/news/10628, "Page 5":/news/10630 Special thanks for your series of stories in the summer _ND Magazine_. It came on a very poignant day for me. One year ago on an equally beautiful Saturday my youngest son sat on my porch to tell me that he "liked boys."

These articles helped me reflect on this last year. A year of great growth for all of us while remaining the same.…

Read More

The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name, p. 5

By Readers

_Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine_ "Page 1":/news/10626, "Page 2":/news/10627, "Page 3":/news/10628, "Page 4":/news/10629 Thank you for publishing this wonderful issue—especially the piece "God Gave me a Gay Son." It is a remarkable journey that this father traveled, and I am so impressed that you published it and shared it with everyone in the ND family. Please pass along my thanks to the author, Thomas Nelson.

Shelly Scheuring '85
Anthem, Arizona…

Read More

Letters from print issue

By Readers

Charges

A brief item in the news section noted that the library is discontinuing 1,500 electronic journal subscriptions and print versions of another 1,000 journals due to a budget crisis. It seems the publishers of the journals, according to the article, "have a captive audience and raise subscription rates faster than inflation." An article on the very next page reports that Notre Dame's tuition next year will jump to $36,930—a 6.9 percent increase. In fact, since my senior year (1977) tuition has increased more than 700 percent. It would appear the administration also has a captive audience and has no qualms about raising tuition rates faster than inflation. In fact, everything—television contracts, football tickets, books, fees, bookstore items, parking permits, etc.—is priced according to what the market will bear. It is hypocritical of Notre Dame to complain when the University takes the same approach.…

Read More

Letters to the Editor Web extra

By Readers

Editor's note: Letters about the summer issue cover package "The Love that Dare Not Speak Its Name" are available at http://magazine.nd.edu/news/10626/

Farewell to some good men

Wow!—I've just finished reading for a second and slow time the beautiful eulogy on Father Edmund P. Joyce, CSC- in the summer 2004 issue. What a Notre Dame man! Thank you so much for selecting a quality writer and contemporary of Father Joyce, Richard Conklin, to prepare the eulogy.

Read More

The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name, p. 1

By Readers

_Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form and from those written or emailed to the magazine._ "Page 2":/news/10627, "Page 3":/news/10628, "Page 4":/news/10629, "Page 5":/news/10630 My reaction to your "homosexuality package" is overwhelmingly favorable. Here are a few comments that I delivered to an 50th anniversary alumni reunion shortly before your package appeared. These comments continue to reflect my views today.

***…

Read More

Reactions to Question of Conscience

By Readers

Editor's note: The following letters were received through the magazine's React Online form. *I read with interest the article,"Question of Conscience"* and found it very intelligent until the author addressed the issue of pro-choice politicians. Appleby's assertion that such a politician is respecting the priority and inviolability of conscience and that somehow that justifies his voting for laws that allow the taking of human life is really very disingenuous. The only way the inviolability of conscience could be given a higher priority than the protection of the unborn is if such politician really did not believe that before birth human beings are entitled to full human rights. Such a position is in direct contradiction to the teachings of the Catholic Church and could only be explained as being the result of poor catechesis or faulty conscience formation on the part of said individual.

I might also add it shows a profound ignorance of or disregard for basic human biology. Catholic politicians who oppose laws that offer protection for the unborn cannot honestly claim that it is their intention to defend the weak and the and vulnerable. To do so represents glaring hypocrisy of the part of Catholic politicians. I am surprised that Appleby did not recognize such a gaping hole in the integrity of what was otherwise such a well-reasoned argument.…

Read More