Prophet of Peace

David Cortright ’68, indefatigable fighter against the forces of war

Author: Patrick Gallagher ’83

Young man in red uniform holds a white dove.
Cortright as the poster boy of GI protest, unaware at the time of photographer Richard Avedon’s acclaim or the icon his image would become; David Cortright in ‘Who Has a Better Right to Oppose the War?’ 1969 / Photograph by Richard Avedon / © The Richard Avedon Foundation

In 1987, David Cortright ’68 spoke to the conference of Germany’s Green Party about the pending Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty, by which the United States and the Soviet Union were agreeing to withdraw all the nuclear missiles and related weaponry with ranges of 300 to 3,400 miles that they had positioned worldwide. The Greens were “unexpectedly glum,” he wrote later, about not having prevented the deployment of these weapons across Europe in the previous decade.

Celebrate your success! he urged them. The memorable moment was one of many across a nearly 60-year career in which the Pennsylvania native has felt compelled to encourage perseverance and hope among peacemakers.

Cortright was then the executive director of the National Committee for a Sane Nuclear Policy, better known as SANE, the leading U.S. nuclear disarmament organization. His exhortation to the German Greens came just a third of the way along that remarkable professional trajectory, starting with protest against the Vietnam War as an enlisted U.S. soldier, before moving first to the frontlines of nuclear disarmament and then to leadership in the opposition to the Iraq War as a central figure in international peace activism and scholarship.

“There are so many dimensions of David’s career that are striking and admirable,” says his onetime boss, R. Scott Appleby ’78, the founding dean of the Keough School of Global Affairs. “He’s indefatigable.” Another colleague, Gerard Powers ’86J.D., ’88M.A., the director of Catholic peacebuilding studies within Keough, echoes the title of his friend’s most beloved course in saying that when Cortright wakes up each morning, “he thinks about how he can help change the world, and he has.”

Cortright retired in 2022 as professor of the practice in Keough and its Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies. Even a condensed recital of his achievements affirms his colleagues’ appraisals. He has authored or edited hundreds of books and articles and done myriad invited talks, panels and media interviews, work that’s been praised by Kofi Annan, the late former secretary-general of the United Nations, Mary Robinson, the former president of Ireland, and the late South African Archbishop Desmond Tutu, among others. In 2004, with his wife, Karen Jacob, Cortright won the Gandhi Peace Award, a prestigious annual prize. Appleby calls him a “public prophet” of nonviolence and peace and “the admired public face of the Kroc Institute.”

As a Notre Dame undergraduate, Cortright studied engineering and joined the baritone horn section of the Marching Band, becoming drum major in his sophomore year. Discovering tastes for philosophy, literature and theology, he settled at last on a history major, an intellectual journey that entailed an “unexpected” faith journey. “I was a devout Catholic,” he says. “But the more theology classes I took, ironically, the more doubts I had about the literal version of the faith.”

Although he wasn’t paying much attention to Vietnam, the war and its domestic discontents were acutely present on campus. In May 1968, for instance, hundreds of students conducted a sit-in to disrupt the ROTC program’s presidential pass in review. The future protester says he considered the demonstration “impolite.”

 

The making of an activist

The war came to Cortright after graduation. His draft notice arrived that summer. He soon decided the war wasn’t for him. Following a high school bandmate’s lead, he says he joined the Army band, deciding a three-year hitch stateside was better than two years in the infantry in Vietnam. He was assigned to the 26th U.S. Army Band at Fort Wadsworth on Staten Island in New York City.

At the base, he heard returning soldiers’ cynicism about the war, which motivated him to study its history. He found that he opposed North Vietnamese leader Ho Chi Minh’s communism, but he was more troubled by what he viewed as an imperialist United States suppressing an indigenous Vietnamese revolution.

Feeling morally conflicted and trapped, he considered desertion but didn’t want to break the law. Conscientious objection required absolute opposition to war, but, he says, “I was an objector to this war,” not to all war. Anger, depression and confusion set in, leaving him feeling “crazy.”

Then he saw Esquire magazine’s August 1968 cover story about an effort to unionize U.S. soldiers in opposition to the conflict. After attending a meeting of antiwar GIs, he committed to the protest movement, reasoning that the country would respond to GI opposition.

Soon he became the face of the movement, literally the poster boy of GI protest. The Student Mobilization Committee — a major student-led organization that opposed the war and the draft and supported Cortright’s military organizing committee — invited him to a New York City studio to pose for a photograph. He neither knew who Vogue magazine photographer Richard Avedon was nor anticipated the icon he himself would become. Avedon’s poster photograph — captioned, “who has a better right to oppose the war?” — featured a uniformed, dove-holding Cortright pop-stylized in milky red, white and blue. Widely used by the antiwar movement, the poster was not meant to be a personal portrait but, as Cortright later wrote in an unpublished memoir, “an image of the antiwar GI as an archetype — the thinking soldier who asserts the right and duty to speak against an illegal and unjust war.”

Meanwhile, he helped organize demonstrations among fellow soldiers, careful to respect military rules: Keep it off base, off duty and out of uniform. Still, as a leading activist, he knew the Army wouldn’t be happy about what he was doing. Events confirmed that.

In November 1969, Cortright was one of many service members who signed a petition in a full-page ad in The New York Times. It began, “We are 1,365 active-duty servicemen. We are opposed to American involvement in the war in Vietnam.” The brass quashed a later petition.

Man with mustache and long hair leans on a briefcase in front of the Supreme Court building.
Cortright took his First Amendment fight to court against U.S. military leaders. AP Photo/Harvey Georges

The following summer, a parade brought things to a head for the drum major and his band. On July 4, 1970, during a civilian parade on Staten Island, band members’ wives and girlfriends marched behind them carrying antiwar signs. Officers lowered the boom, consigning the musicians to basic duties that did not include music and transferring “troublemakers.” They sent Cortright to Fort Bliss in Texas.

Claiming infringements on their First Amendment rights, Cortright and others immediately sued Secretary of the Army Stanley Resor in federal court. Arguing that the Army had transferred him to suppress his protests, he sought a restraining order and civil (as opposed to military) jurisdiction. The Army countered that it allowed dissent and that the transfers were not ordered to punish protest. The judge denied the restraining order, so Cortright went to Texas, but took jurisdiction, and the case continued.

In the 1970-71 trial of Cortright v. Resor, the chief of staff of the First U.S. Army testified that the women’s protest during the parade had incited the Army’s concern. During cross-examination, Cortright’s attorney goaded the annoyed general into admitting the transfers aimed to remove the troublemakers, proving the plaintiffs’ case. The judge found for the soldiers, voiding their transfers. The Army appealed, winning reversal in a 2-1 appellate court decision. The U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear Cortright’s appeal.

Five decades later, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York City included Cortright v. Resor in its Justice for All program that reenacts significant trials for educational purposes. The case was selected, says Senior Judge Denny Chin, because it “raised important issues about the First Amendment rights of soldiers: do they have First Amendment rights; to what extent can soldiers express disagreement with a war in which they are involved; to what extent, if at all, can courts address these issues?” Among other venues, the trial was presented at Notre Dame Law School in 2019.

Remaining in Texas, Cortright continued to protest until his discharge in 1971.

The experience of military service clouded the lives of many Vietnam War veterans. For Cortright, it was illuminating. “In a curious way the Army did me a favor by sending that induction notice so many years ago,” he wrote about the draft in his unpublished memoir. “I was wrenched out of confusion and uncertainty into a life of direction and purpose. Working for peace became the answer to my existential questioning.”

Though that questioning had challenged his religious faith, he credits his Catholicism with implanting values that encouraged his active-duty protests. “We as believing people are to respect others and try to love our enemies, to help those in need, to work for peace,” he says.

 

Antinuclear movement leader

During his military service, Cortright completed a master’s degree in history at New York University. After his discharge, he worked in think tanks addressing military conditions, racism and union issues, and in 1975 obtained a doctorate in political science from The Union Institute. His dissertation on soldier dissent in Vietnam became his first book, Soldiers in Revolt: GI Resistance During the Vietnam War.

A few years later, impressed by Cortright’s Vietnam-era organizing experience and his scholarship, SANE approached him about its executive director position. He shared the organization’s support for complete nuclear disarmament, but it faced debt and declining membership. Nevertheless, he took the job in 1978.

The country may have been ready for a reenergized SANE. The existence of tens of thousands of weapons worldwide produced a “palpable fear” of nuclear war, Cortright says. People responded to SANE’s door-to-door solicitations, and membership grew from a few thousand to about 150,000 by the mid-1980s.

Brewster Rhoads, then the executive director of a coalition of 55 progressive organizations that included SANE, says that under Cortright, SANE became “the national leader in mobilizing public opinion and focusing it on Congress” around SANE’s priorities: banning the MX missile and neutron bomb and promoting the “nuclear freeze,” a growing international movement calling on the U.S. and the Soviet Union to halt the testing, production and deployment of nuclear weapons. “Dave was the recognized smartest guy in the room,” Rhoads says. “When he spoke, everyone listened, not only because of his knowledge of the issues themselves, but his strategic thinking about what needed to be done to actually impact public policy.”

In the early 1980s, SANE allied itself with the nuclear freeze movement. Cortright hired lobbyists for Capitol Hill outreach and, in 1982, created a political action committee to support sympathetic candidates and dozens of statewide and local nuclear freeze referendums around the country. “You needed activism in the streets and advocacy in the suites,” he says.

Central to the activism was a rally in New York’s Central Park in June 1982. Cortright remembers human rights activist Cora Weiss describing her ambition to bring a million people to New York during the United Nations’ special disarmament session. The dream generated an organizing committee of more than 100 groups, including SANE. The New York Police Department handled security, and popular musicians performed at what is widely considered the largest peace protest in U.S. history. Most importantly, Cortright says, “it showed that people wanted the arms race to stop.” Meanwhile, as proof of advocacy’s effectiveness, that fall’s freeze-related state and local ballot issues passed with an average of 60 percent approval.

That work gained access to the highest suites. During the 1985 U.S.-Soviet summit in Geneva, Switzerland, Cortright, Rev. Jesse Jackson and other antinuclear leaders met with Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev to discuss nuclear and human rights issues.

Man with mustache in a suit and tie looks up.
‘You needed activism in the streets and advocacy in the suites,’ says Cortright, above, testifying in Congress as the leader of SANE, which supported a massive 1982 nuclear disarmament demonstration in New York’s Central Park.

Jackson’s Operation PUSH was a SANE ally. Invited by Jackson to a worship service, Cortright was thrilled “to see the way in which the social gospel orientation was front and center.” The experience awakened Cortright’s religious sensibilities and brought him “back to the gospel and to a commitment to working for justice and peace, not only as a political phenomenon, but as an expression of my faith.” He experienced a “similar thrill” when he revisited Pope John XXIII’s 1963 encyclical, Pacem in Terris. In its criticism of the arms race and promotion of social justice, he recognized “the Church I used to be part of.”

In addition to the wins of the freeze campaign, the advocacy successes of Cortright’s tenure at SANE include curtailment of the MX missile and contributions to several policy and diplomatic efforts: the U.S. nuclear testing moratorium, the INF treaty, the Strategic Arms Limitation Talks and other treaties that eliminated many nuclear weapons. After facilitating the organizational merger that created SANE/Freeze in the late 1980s, Cortright left in 1989 to pursue an academic career in peace studies. He heard international relations scholar George Lopez, newly ensconced at Notre Dame’s Kroc Institute, speak at a conference. Lopez, the Rev. Theodore M. Hesburgh Professor Emeritus of Peace Studies, remembers Cortright “bouncing down” the stairs afterward to learn about Kroc, and he encouraged his new friend to visit.

 

How to change careers

Having hardly returned to campus since his graduation, Cortright joined an alumni club trip to the 1988 Notre Dame-Miami football game. For him, the highlight was visiting Kroc’s small office in the Law School. Lopez recommended Cortright to Jack Gilligan ’43, the former Ohio governor then serving as Kroc’s first director. Gilligan wanted an instructor with experience in peace activism and arms control, practical skills to complement the academic faculty. The job description could have been written for Cortright, and he became Kroc’s first visiting faculty fellow in 1989.

Gilligan introduced him to Howard Brembeck, founder of the Fourth Freedom Forum in Goshen, Indiana, which focused on the last of President Franklin Roosevelt’s Four Freedoms — freedom from fear. “David was drawn to Howard’s philosophy linking economic interdependence, trade, sanctions and peace,” Lopez recalls. Over the next decade, pursuing an entrepreneurial partnership, Cortright worked variously for Kroc and the forum.

Following the 1991 Gulf War, launched in response to Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait, Brembeck, a political conservative who was opposed to nuclear weapons and the resumption of war in Iraq and instead saw business as the way to peace, joined those who promoted sanctions rather than military intervention as a tool to pressure rogue nations like Iraq to respect international norms. The United Nations defines sanctions as “a broad range of enforcement options that do not involve the use of armed force.”

The U.N. adopted this approach, imposing sanctions on Iraq to disarm it of its weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and contain its autocratic president, Saddam Hussein. Specific tactics included a trade embargo, a freeze on the country’s financial assets, restrictions on its military, an oil-export ban and inspections and elimination of Iraq’s WMD.

Large crowd gathered in a park with a stage in the distance and city skyline beyond.
AP Photo/Ray Stubblebine

While many in the peace and diplomatic communities supported sanctions over war to contain Iraq, some humanitarians asserted that they harmed innocent people. Cortright and Lopez explored the question. Through the next decade, Brembeck’s organization supported their research on the sanctions’ effects. They found that the weapons inspections were dramatically dismantling Iraq’s chemical, biological and nuclear weapons programs, but the economic measures shrank the Iraqi economy, degraded its infrastructure and reduced access to clean water, food and health care. Among the direct consequences were widespread malnutrition, severe distress and premature death among the Iraqi population.

In the 1990s and early 2000s, Cortright and Lopez published five books and several reports documenting these effects. As they wrote in 1999, after the sanctions had achieved their military objectives, the scholars argued they had become “increasingly punitive and discriminatory.”

“That’s when we became involved in the debate at the U.N. about ‘smart sanctions,’” Cortright says. Aiming to reduce adverse impacts on civilians, smart sanctions used tools such as travel watchlists, sector-specific restrictions and asset freezes to target those who profited from wrongful behavior.

Loraine Rickard-Martin, then a senior political affairs officer at the U.N. Security Council, says Cortright and Lopez “were among the preeminent U.N. sanctions policy and implementation experts” working with the international body and its member states. They were able to “introduce genuinely innovative, even groundbreaking policy concepts into a highly charged political environment — and do so in a way that allowed political actors to take ownership of those ideas.” It “was astute and imaginative but also marked by a low-key humility that often masked just how consequential their thinking and impact really was.”

Rickard-Martin recalls walking into a high-level meeting with the two men. Cortright said something like, Can you believe this? Two guys from Indiana advising the U.N. Security Council? “It caught me off guard,” she remembers, “because they were among the most brilliant policy minds I’d worked with. They were taken seriously inside the system, consistently respected for bringing evidence, clarity and a constructive, solutions-oriented mindset.”

In 2002, Cortright, Lopez and Fourth Freedom Forum vice president Alistair Millar produced “Winning Without War,” a major policy paper summarizing the successes of the Iraq weapons inspectors. It argued that a mix of sanctions, incentives and high-tech monitoring could achieve U.S. goals and avoid war. Says Appleby, “Their work exemplified politically engaged, policy-relevant scholarship, even if it didn’t prevent war.” Hindsight says it should have.

On Iraq, Cortright’s approach to advocacy was somewhat inverted from his SANE playbook. This time he started in the suites with U.N. delegates and moved to the streets to engage demonstrators. When his research was rejected by policymakers bent on war, he joined the massive global antiwar protest and helped found Win Without War, an organization that prioritized media, messaging and quick response to influence public opinion. It also aimed to separate opposition to war from antagonism toward military personnel, a lesson learned from Vietnam and the hostility toward soldiers held by some in that antiwar movement.

Ignoring the protests and disputing the success of the sanctions and inspections, the Bush administration launched the Iraq War in March 2003. But as “shock and awe” faded, and U.S. military inspectors could find no evidence of Iraq’s presumed stockpiles of WMD, public opinion on the war shifted. Some in the military community feared that American soldiers weren’t adequately equipped with body armor and armored vehicles. Others objected to the war’s aims. After reading Cortright’s Soldiers in Revolt, some sailors opposed to the war conferred with him about resistance. One result was the 2007 Appeal for Redress, in which service members used First Amendment language to call directly on Congress to end the war. Like the New York Times ad Cortright signed four decades earlier, it bore more than 1,000 signatures.

In his 2023 book, A Peaceful Superpower: Lessons from the World’s Largest Antiwar Movement, Cortright asserted that the movement’s arguments against the Iraq war were proven correct. At the outset of the fighting, he argued, “there was no evidence of WMD, U.N. inspections and sanctions were working, and invading and occupying the country would lead to chaos and an increase in terrorist violence. . . . They should have listened to us.”

Man in blue shirt and white cap sits on rocks by the water.
Matt Cashore ’94

 

How to change the world

When the University’s president, Rev. Theodore Hesburgh, CSC, established the Kroc Institute in 1986, he was clear that it should avoid being antimilitary. Honoring Hesburgh’s vision, Cortright organized regular conversations between ROTC leaders and Kroc peace faculty. Kelly Jordan, commander of Notre Dame’s Army ROTC program from 2004 to 2007, says participants discussed world events on a “nonattribution basis” so all could feel free to speak. Jordan believes the image of uniformed ROTC officers walking across campus to Kroc’s offices exemplified the civil-military relationship.

In the mid-2010s, tasked with developing the future Keough School, Appleby experienced pushback from the University’s independent institutes and centers of international study, such as Kroc, that figured to be gathered under the Keough umbrella and feared losing “sovereignty” under a new dean. He enlisted Cortright’s help. “David has always been levelheaded, with an abundance of common sense,” he says. The peacemaker mustered the necessary support.

Appleby would turn again to Cortright to lead Kroc’s signature Peace Accords Matrix (PAM) program, whose database of peace agreements helps evaluate their implementation. Cortright didn’t need another assignment, Appleby admits, and it was heavy administrative work that “prophets aren’t always called to.” But the “team player” successfully managed the program for four years starting in 2016, a period that included oversight of Kroc’s role in monitoring the Colombian peace process.

U.S. Senate staffer Elizabeth Boyle ’20, ’23MGA, one of Cortright’s former students, often heard PAM praised for its practical utility during her internship in Rome as a mediator on the Community of Sant’Egidio’s international relations team. As a student, she waited years to take Cortright’s How to Change the World class, which he says aimed to create “practical and effective change advocates.” It laid out the principles of nonviolence and strategies of social action. After studying real-world cases, Cortright’s students formed teams to develop strategies for social action campaigns.

Discovering the class in high school while researching peace studies programs, Boyle found it worth the wait. Cortright made the “grand idea of how to change the world . . . accessible,” she says. This was especially pertinent at Notre Dame, where “being a force for good is kind of marked into your brain from the day you set foot on campus.” Inspired, she cofounded Stand for Nine, a project responding to the rollback of Title IX protections. In “a full-circle moment,” Cortright invited her to speak to his class about it.

Cortright taught How to Change the World for a decade or more, yielding hundreds of students who are now professionals “out there doing it,” Lopez says. The research partners shared the “confidence that maybe some things we wrote would have an immediate effect,” he adds, “but the enduring effect is the people you teach.”

One of those students, Peter Quaranto ’06, a former Senate staffer, State Department official and Keough visiting professor, says something Cortright emphasized at the end of his nonviolent social change course became a “north star” for his career: “This work is a marathon. It’s not a sprint. . . . Ultimately, we should all think about our work as the long journey that we’re engaged in over this full span of our life.”

Two men in suits converse near beige stone columns.
Cortright and Lopez on campus in 2006; Matt Cashore ’94

Asked about the origins of Cortright’s life mission, Appleby suggests that as a Notre Dame student Cortright “absorbed, as all of us did, the Catholic thing: . . . Catholic anthropology, Catholic sensibilities, Catholic attitudes toward war and peace.”

Lopez says one of Cortright’s enduring contributions to peace studies is his “demonstration that you can be a loyal American [and], whether as a soldier or as a policy person or as an academic, . . . you can dramatically disagree with policy and do it constructively and without vitriol, without preaching.”

Now, nearly 40 years after that 1987 speech to the German Greens, which once seemed to mark the beginning of the end of the nuclear age, many accomplishments of these peace movements have unraveled. Major weapons treaties have expired. Countries threaten to resume nuclear testing and flout sanctions. Today we witness saber-rattling and war over nuclear policy in Iran. How does a peace worker abide?

Cortright remains cheerful in the face of resistance and setbacks, but his perseverance is fueled by religious belief. “I am a person of faith,” he says, “and I act to try to bring about a more peaceful and just world, not because I expect to achieve success in the moment, but because it’s the right thing to do.”

As he acknowledges the challenges, he also waves aside any pessimistic emphasis on loss. “We helped to reverse the arms race and prevent nuclear war. That’s pretty important,” he says. “Even today, with the ending of the last arms agreement, you haven’t seen a rush to build more warheads.” As for Vietnam and Iraq, he adds, protest played its part in moving political leaders to end both wars. Those efforts saved lives.

Nonetheless, the question about endurance is one this peacemaker hears often these days. “I really have a strong belief that we don’t have the right to be pessimistic and to give up,” he says. “There are too many people whose lives are at stake.”


Patrick Gallagher lives and writes in Aberdeen, South Dakota.